Long Tin Shum
Long Tin Shum
Film critic
Hong Kong
Voted in the critics poll
Hong Kong
Voted in the critics poll
Voted for:
| Aguirre, Wrath of God | 1972 | Werner Herzog |
| Ashes of Time | 1994 | Wong Kar Wai |
| Blow Up | 1966 | Michelangelo Antonioni |
| Breathless | 1960 | Jean-Luc Godard |
| dolce vita, La | 1960 | Federico Fellini |
| Innocent, The | 1976 | Luchino Visconti |
| Last Year At Marienbad | 1961 | Alain Resnais |
| Obscure Object of Desire, That | 1977 | Luis Buñuel |
| Règle du jeu, La | 1939 | Jean Renoir |
| Stalker | 1979 | Andrei Tarkovsky |

Comments
Alain Resnais’ Last Year in Marrienbad is a full exploration of the meaning of narrative truth in cinema. The audience will always be absorbed in the labyrinth of desire and signs and never want to come out. Is the fate of the one who can never enter the Room but must always be guide for others the destiny of a humble artist? Stalker is so tender, so moving and so poetic. Breathless has an excellent mise en scène and explores how narration merges with meta-film reflections. The Innocent shows the power of elegent indulence as aesthetics of cinema. Blow-Up is another reflection on reality and the intolerance of art, and is so rich in visual layers. Federico Fellini, La Dolce Vita suceeded in bringing out the notion of the dialectic bittersweet relationship. It’s also a strong criticism of capitalist city lives. Ashes of Time is a deep and double-edged discourse on love, refined with classic dialogue. Aguirre, Wrath of God reminds us the absurdity of life and the arrogance of human beings – the images of vanity; the sighs of actuality. That Obscure Object of Desire is the perfect exhibition of the structure of desire, and is powerfully imagined. The Rules of Game may be the greatest film in history.