Antonio Rodrigues
Antonio Rodrigues
Programmer, Cinemateca Portuguesa
Portugal
Voted in the critics poll
Portugal
Voted in the critics poll
Voted for:
| Angel | 1937 | Ernst Lubitsch |
| Birth of a Nation, The | 1915 | D.W. Griffith |
| Greed | 1925 | Erich von Stroheim |
| Hawks and Sparrows | 1966 | Pier Paolo Pasolini |
| I, a Negro | 1959 | Jean Rouch |
| M | 1931 | Fritz Lang |
| mépris, Le | 1963 | Jean-Luc Godard |
| Music Room, The | 1958 | Satyajit Ray |
| Rear Window | 1954 | Alfred Hitchcock |
| Règle du jeu, La | 1939 | Jean Renoir |

Comments
This is a list of ten examples of the greatest films of all time: they are very dense cinematographic objects, absolutely perfect or absolutely new from a formal point of view. And, naturally, they touch us emotionally. Absolutely perfect: Angel (the use of on and offscreen space); Rear Window (the perfect metaphor of the relationship between spectator and cinema); Jalsaghar (its sheer beauty); M (the incredibly intelligent use of the a new medium – sound); The Birth of a Nation (yes, it is racist, but it is also a masterpiece of mise en scène); Greed (the silent period was a golden age). Absolutely new: Le Mépris (every great film is also a film about cinema, but this one is only about cinema); La règle du jeu (a non-masterpiece, open to a hundred different analyses); Moi, un noir (the camera itself has a new function).